I, like most gamers I know, have been eagerly awaiting Rock Band since it was announced. The ability to form bands and play over the internet together is fucking awesome. As much as I like Guitar Hero, I had sort of written the game off when Rock Band was announced. Not because I thought the third one was going to be a bad game, but because, you know, Rock Band.
And while I’m still looking forward to Rock Band, I think I’m actually looking forward to Guitar Hero 3 even more. The guys over at ScoreHero.com recently visited Neversoft to play the new Guitar Hero and came back with the goods. It sounds fucking awesome. The controller looks sweet (confidential to Harmonix: Fender Strats are fucking lame) and it sounds like Neversoft understands the pressure they’re under. They know they have something to prove and they know that the Rock Band wolves are at the fucking door. They’re making a lot of tweaks, big and small, and the ScoreHero guys are saying that GH3 is a big leap forward for the franchise. Also, confidential to people who were worried about Neversoft and Activision filling Guitar Hero with bullshit tracks: the Tony Hawk games have had fucking kick-ass music for almost a decade. Get with it.
Speaking of tracks (take that, segue!) let’s go over the confirmed track listings for each game, shall we? I’ll make notes about my feelings for each one:
GUITAR HERO 3
01. “Barracuda” – Heart: This song is fucking awesome.
02. “Cherub Rock” – Smashing Pumpkins: I hate the Smashing Pumpkins, but this song would be awesome to play in the game.
03. “Cult of Personality” – Living Colour: I used to like this song when I was little. I think it would be great for the game.
04. “Even Flow” – Pearl Jam: Meh.
05. “Knights of Cydonia” – Muse: I don’t know who this is.
06. “La Grange - ZZ Top: ZZ Top fucking blows.
07. “Lay Down” – Priestess: This song is amazing.
08. “The Metal” – Tenacious D: Meh.
09. “My Name Is Jonas” – Weezer: Meh.
10. “The Number of the Beast” - Iron Maiden: One of the best songs ever written. HO. LY. SHIT.
11. “Paint It Black” – The Rolling Stones: The only Rolling Stones song that I like. I’m stoked on this one.
12. “Rock and Roll All Nite” – Kiss: The only better Kiss song they could have done would be “Detroit Rock City.” This song rules.
13. “Rock You Like a Hurricane” – Scorpions: This song is going to be hilariously awesome to play.
14. “Sabotage” – Beastie Boys: This song kind of changes things up a bit. I’m looking forward to playing the bass part!
15. “School’s Out” – Alice Cooper: The Alice Cooper song they should have had in 2. Totally awesome.
16. “She Builds Quick Machines” – Velvet Revolver: This band sucks.
17. “Slow Ride” – Foghat: Shitty song, amazing GH material.
18. “Suck My Kiss” - Red Hot Chili Peppers: This is a master track, so it should be sweet.
19. “Welcome to the Jungle” – Guns N’ Roses: Fucking finally. This song rules.
ROCK BAND
01. “(Don’t Fear) The Reaper” – Blue Öyster Cult: This song is awesome. I can’t wait to play it.
02. “Enter Sandman” – Metallica: This song is fucking terrible. Why wouldn’t you pick an old Metallica song?
03. “Go with the Flow” – Queens of the Stone Age: Meh.
04. “In Bloom” – Nirvana: This song would be sweet on drums, lame on everything else.
05. “Learn To Fly” – Foo Fighters: This song seriously sucks.
06. “Main Offender” – The Hives: This song rules.
07. “Mississippi Queen” – Mountain: Lame.
08. “Paranoid” – Black Sabbath: A sweet song, but the worst one from this album. “Fairies Wear Boots” would have been way sweeter.
09. “Reptilia” – The Strokes: The Strokes? Ugh.
10. “Rockaway Beach” – The Ramones: The Ramones? Are you fucking kidding me?
11. “Say It Ain’t So” – Weezer: This song sucks, but it could be fun to play.
12. “Suffragette City” – David Bowie: This song is awesome, but I don’t know that it would be that fun to play.
13. “Tom Sawyer” – Rush: Rush is one of the worst bands in the history of music.
14. “Vasoline” – Stone Temple Pilots: Ditto.
15. “Wanted Dead or Alive” – Bon Jovi: Are there even drums on this song? I guess it doesn’t matter because it sucks.
16. “Won’t Get Fooled Again” – The Who: With very few exceptions, the Who are a fucking musical crime against humanity.
So there are thirteen GH3 songs that I’m looking forward to on some level, and maybe four songs that I’m looking forward to for Rock Band. As of right now, the scales are tipped towards GH3. Both games have in the realm of 50 or so songs left to announce, but if you were to project the percentages out as they stand, there’s already a pretty big gap this early in the process. I’m hoping that both games announce some more recent tracks instead of leaning so heavily on old shit. There are a lot of sweet metal bands out there that would be a perfect fit for both games.
Perhaps even more distressing for Rock Band is the fact that Harmonix and MTV brought Steve Van Zandt onboard to help pick music for the game. Yes, that Steve Van Zandt. The fucking old guy from Bruce Springsteen’s E-Street Band. I actually don’t think that it’s humanly possible to get less cool than that. There goes all your street cred, guys. I’ll take Priestess any day of the week, thank you.
So that’s sort of where I stand right now. I think that the idea for Rock Band is amazing and I don’t doubt that it will be an awesome game, but it’s really tough for me to muster much enthusiasm for anything that Steve Van Zandt is associated with, not to mention that they’re 16 songs into the final list and I’m not really feeling it. For the moment, I’m much more excited about Guitar Hero 3. While not quite as ambitious in scope, Neversoft seems to be making some great steps forward with it and they’re really honing and perfecting the concept. Maybe most importantly, at least for me, that’s where the songs are. While I know that I’ll eventually end up with both, right now GH3 is my must-buy.